Skip to main content

RI's Transition No Model for Egypt

(published by The Jakarta Post on 18 Feb 2011. Click here)


After the resignation of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak on Feb. 11, Egyptians need to realize that the path to democracy that they have dreamed about for so long is still a long journey. If they are expecting democracy immediately after successfully toppling their president, who was in power for 30 years, they will very soon be disappointed.

Mubarak is gone. The people are joyous and euphoric after their victory, but beware! That was just one day. There are hundreds and even thousands of days in the future. Egyptians should move forward but there is no toll road to a democratic destiny. We know that exchanging authoritarian rule with democratic rule is about dealing with chronic illness, and it is painful and everyone needs to understand this.

All the media in the world had headlines about Mubarak’s resignation, underlining the word “freedom”. On Feb. 11, after Vice President Omar Suleiman announced that Mubarak had decided to step down, the media reported Egyptians of all ages jamming the banks of the Nile and the squares of Cairo waving flags, lighting fireworks and shouting “freedom”.

Is that freedom from Hosni Mubarak, or freedom from what?


We, Indonesians, have experienced our country’s transition to democracy. We have had a taste of freedom (from Suharto’s authoritarian rule), but, after more than twelve years, the question remains: “Is democracy in our country true freedom and prosperity for the people?” This is only one question. We still have plenty of questions about whether we have true freedom in the context of religion, human rights, minority protection, law enforcement, bribery, corruption, poverty etc.

Many political analysts compare what’s happening in Egypt with what happened in Indonesia in 1998. Even in the United States the Obama administration used Indonesia as a model for Egypt’s transition. President Obama in a speech on Friday, Feb. 11, compared Egypt’s revolution to Indonesia’s. This is logical because the two countries were very similar in the process of regime substitution.

But, the world should not stop with the revolution and transition similarities. The world should also notice that Indonesia’s journey to democracy has almost failed because democracy in Indonesia has gone too far. Democracy in Indonesia has veered from idealism and, unfortunately, has resulted in a weak government. This weak government has dragged Indonesia into its leadership crisis today.

Several cases, from the Gayus saga to the Ahmadiyah attack in Pandeglang, Banten, to the vandalism of churches in Temanggung, Central Java, recently have shown us that this country is run without strong leadership. Is this democracy? A democracy where people can persecute others freely and the government seems too afraid to take stern action against organized attackers?

erhaps the Egyptians have learned from Indonesia in fighting against dictatorship, but they should also learn how to guard the process of a democratic transition, including how to form not only a democratic government but a strong government. Otherwise, they will follow Indonesia and become a failing nation.

***
Serpong, Feb 13, 2011
Titus J.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Perhentian Ahok di KM 19.4

Ketika angka quick count hasil perolehan suara Pilkada Jakarta 19 April yang lalu menunjukkan 42 persen untuk Ahok-Djarot dan 58 persen untuk Anies-Sandi, banyak yang terkesima, sedih, dan tak sedikit yang menangis. Herannya, yang menangis bukan hanya orang Jakarta, tetapi juga mereka yang tinggal di luar Jakarta, bahkan luar negeri. Media sosial riuh-rendah dengan komentar, seolah tak percaya dengan angka yang terpampang di televisi dan berseliweran melalui WhatsApp group. Di saat itulah tiba-tiba kita merasakan ada sesuatu yang hilang - sesuatu yang pernah kita miliki, yang pernah mewarnai denyut kehidupan kita walau hanya lewat surat kabar dan media sosial, dan sesuatu yang selalu kita rasakan kehadirannya walaupun jarak memisahkan. Kita – bukan cuma orang Jakarta tetapi siapapun yang selama empat tahunan ini menyemai harapan dan optimisme, tiba-tiba secara bersamaan membisikkan tanya, “Bagaimana rupa Jakarta nanti tanpa Ahok?” Tanggal 19 April itu seperti satu titik di ...

Forgive Me for Not to Obey Your Fatwa

It’s still fresh in my mind, where Megawati’s PDI (Indonesia Democracy Party) harshly knocked-out by Suharto’s power in 1996. I was still 3 months since I set my feet on Jakarta from my hometown. Everybody knew Megawati was a serious menace of Suharto’s Golkar at that time, and 1996 was only a year ahead of the election. Like previous elections, Golkar always wanted vote majority in order to keep Suharto in reign. Time could not be stopped and Megawati popularity has made the Suharto’s circle depressed. They seemed so fearful the Soekarno’s spirit was coming back. With a very dirt scenario, Suharto’s regime created drama by conspiring with several PDI executives to organize a congress in Medan. The congress, as predicted clearly by everyone, finally appointed Soerjadi as PDI chairman, Fatimah Ahmad as deputy chairman and Butu Hutapea as the secretary general (Soerjadi is Megawati’s predecessor). It means, Megawati who had been selected by National Meeting in Surabaya in 1993, was kick...

The Lawmakers Are Too Proud to be God

My brain suddenly becomes so blunt to understand how some members of Commission VII of the House of Representatives (DPR) use their "looked smart" brain to think smartly. In the hearing between the lawmakers and Pertamina management on February 10, 2009, one of the lawmakers, Effendi Simbolon, humiliated Karen Agustiawan, the CEO of Pertamina by saying she was un-competent to lead the big organization as Pertamina – the prestigious State Owned Company in oil & gas and geothermal energy sector. They even harshly bullied her by putting label on her as Satpam (private security guard) if Karen could not stay away from serving the interest of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and VP Jusuf Kalla. It’s clear to people that some of the “supposed to be respected” lawmakers do not deserve to receive any respects. That is why they cannot respect others, too. They have been acting as judge, even God, when they summon government officials or businessmen to their nest. They grill eve...