Skip to main content

RI's Transition No Model for Egypt

(published by The Jakarta Post on 18 Feb 2011. Click here)


After the resignation of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak on Feb. 11, Egyptians need to realize that the path to democracy that they have dreamed about for so long is still a long journey. If they are expecting democracy immediately after successfully toppling their president, who was in power for 30 years, they will very soon be disappointed.

Mubarak is gone. The people are joyous and euphoric after their victory, but beware! That was just one day. There are hundreds and even thousands of days in the future. Egyptians should move forward but there is no toll road to a democratic destiny. We know that exchanging authoritarian rule with democratic rule is about dealing with chronic illness, and it is painful and everyone needs to understand this.

All the media in the world had headlines about Mubarak’s resignation, underlining the word “freedom”. On Feb. 11, after Vice President Omar Suleiman announced that Mubarak had decided to step down, the media reported Egyptians of all ages jamming the banks of the Nile and the squares of Cairo waving flags, lighting fireworks and shouting “freedom”.

Is that freedom from Hosni Mubarak, or freedom from what?


We, Indonesians, have experienced our country’s transition to democracy. We have had a taste of freedom (from Suharto’s authoritarian rule), but, after more than twelve years, the question remains: “Is democracy in our country true freedom and prosperity for the people?” This is only one question. We still have plenty of questions about whether we have true freedom in the context of religion, human rights, minority protection, law enforcement, bribery, corruption, poverty etc.

Many political analysts compare what’s happening in Egypt with what happened in Indonesia in 1998. Even in the United States the Obama administration used Indonesia as a model for Egypt’s transition. President Obama in a speech on Friday, Feb. 11, compared Egypt’s revolution to Indonesia’s. This is logical because the two countries were very similar in the process of regime substitution.

But, the world should not stop with the revolution and transition similarities. The world should also notice that Indonesia’s journey to democracy has almost failed because democracy in Indonesia has gone too far. Democracy in Indonesia has veered from idealism and, unfortunately, has resulted in a weak government. This weak government has dragged Indonesia into its leadership crisis today.

Several cases, from the Gayus saga to the Ahmadiyah attack in Pandeglang, Banten, to the vandalism of churches in Temanggung, Central Java, recently have shown us that this country is run without strong leadership. Is this democracy? A democracy where people can persecute others freely and the government seems too afraid to take stern action against organized attackers?

erhaps the Egyptians have learned from Indonesia in fighting against dictatorship, but they should also learn how to guard the process of a democratic transition, including how to form not only a democratic government but a strong government. Otherwise, they will follow Indonesia and become a failing nation.

***
Serpong, Feb 13, 2011
Titus J.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Eisenhower, The Top Figure Army General, The Modest President

This is a portrait of Dwight D. Eisenhower, a young dreamer, charting a course from Abilene, Kansas, to West Point and beyond. Before becoming the 34th president (two terms from 1953 to 1961), Ike –as he was called–  was a five-star general in the U.S. Army during World War II and served as Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force in Europe. This book reveals the journey of the man who worked with incredible subtlety to move events in the direction he wished them to go. In both war and peace, he gave the world confidence in American leadership. In the war period, Ike commanded the largest multinational force ever assembled to fight German troops in leading the Western powers to victory.  During his presidency, he ended a three-year war in Korea with honor and dignity. Not a single American died in combat for the next eight years. He resisted calls for preventive war against the Soviet Union and China, faced down Khruschev over Berlin, and restored stability in Leban...
Post a Comment
Read more

Bertrand Russell Critical Analysis on Western Philosophy

“Philosophy is something intermediate between theology and science,” said Bertrand Russell. Theology and science occupy their own territory. All definite knowledge belongs to science, all dogma as to what surpasses definite knowledge belongs to theology. Between theology and science there is No Man’s Land, exposed to attack from both sides. For that the philosophy is present. The No Man’s Land is philosophy. Then he added, “Philosophical conceptions are a product of two factors: one, inherited religious and ethical conceptions; the other, the sort of investigation which may be called ‘scientific’.” Bertrand Russell who was born in 1872, he himself was a British philosopher as well as mathematician, logician, historian, writer, and social critic. In this book, which was firstly published in 1945, Russell divided the philosophy chronologically into three parts: Ancient Philosophy, Catholic Philosophy and Modern Philosophy. This book is a widely read and influential philosophical history ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Jesus Way Tak Segampang Busway

Jesus Way yang diartikan “cara Yesus” atau “jalan Yesus” tampaknya berupa jalan sempit dan sedikit orang menyukainya/memilihnya. Ini pernah dikatakan oleh Yesus sendiri: “ Karena sesaklah pintu dan sempitlah jalan yang menuju kepada kehidupan, dan sedikit orang yang mendapatinya .” (Matius 7:14). Semua orang, atau sebagian besar orang, memilih jalan lebar tanpa hambatan agar sebisa mungkin lebih cepat sampai tujuan. Jalan sempit hanya memperlama waktu, tidak efektif, dan tidak sesuai tuntutan zaman yang serba cepat dan instan. Sebenarnya jalan sempit tidak apa-apa asalkan lancar. Ternyata tidak. Jesus way bukan seperti jalur khusus bus atau busway di Jakarta. Busway – walaupun sempit, hanya pas untuk satu bus – memberikan privilege karena dikhususkan untuk bus tanpa ada hambatan apapun. Ikut melaju di busway enak sekali, diprioritaskan, tidak ikut ngantri bermacet-macetan di jalan. Jesus way tidak seperti busway . Dulu ada kisah seorang anak muda yang kaya raya, yang sedang mencar...
Post a Comment
Read more